Private elementary schools in Whitefish Bay, WI (38)

On the official list

Affiliation, co-ed or single-sex, association membership and the share of graduates going on to a 4-year college come from the 2023-24 federal Private School Universe survey.

Holy Family Parish School

under 1 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 141 students 10.1 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

4849 N Wildwood Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Call (414) 332-8175 School facts Compare

Bader Hillel Academy

1 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades K-8 161 students 6 students per teacher Jewish Co-ed

6401 N Santa Monica Blvd, Milwaukee, WI 53217

Call (414) 962-9545 School facts Website Compare

Eastbrook Academy

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-12 384 students 11.6 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed 100% to 4-year college

5375 N Green Bay Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53209

Call (414) 228-7905 School facts Website Compare

St. Robert School

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 261 students 11.2 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

2200 E Capitol Dr, Shorewood, WI 53211

Call (414) 332-1164 School facts Website Compare

Messmer Catholic Schools

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-12 1,180 students 13.5 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed 65% to 4-year college

742 W Capitol Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53206

Call (414) 264-5440 School facts Website Compare

Divine Destiny School

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades PreK-8 90 students 22.5 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed

3782 N 12th St., Milwaukee, WI 53206

Call (414) 264-3374 School facts Website Compare

Hope Christian School - Fortis

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades PreK-8 319 students 21.3 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed

3601 N Port Washington Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53212

Call (414) 264-6284 School facts Website Compare

Garden Homes Lutheran School

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 238 students 21.6 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

2450 W Roosevelt Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53209

Call (414) 444-9050 School facts Website Compare

Malaika Early Learning Center

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades PreK-3 68 students 7.6 students per teacher Nonsectarian Co-ed

125 W Auer Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53212

Call (414) 562-4997 School facts Website Compare

Believers in Christ Christian Academy

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades PreK-12 145 students 11.5 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed 100% to 4-year college

4065 N 25th St., Milwaukee, WI 53209

Call (414) 444-7146 School facts Website Compare

Siloah Lutheran School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades K-8 79 students 11.3 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

3721 N 21st St., Milwaukee, WI 53206

Call (414) 873-8240 School facts Compare

Carter's Christian Academy

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-12 265 students 22.1 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed 100% to 4-year college

5268 N 35th St., Milwaukee, WI 53209

Call (414) 248-9271 School facts Website Compare

St. Eugene School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 144 students 9.6 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

7600 N Port Washington Rd, Fox Point, WI 53217

Call (414) 420-6173 School facts Website Compare

Hope Christian School-Semper

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades PreK-8 497 students 24.9 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed

3040 W Capitol Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53216

Call (414) 323-0748 School facts Website Compare

St. Johns Lutheran School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 92 students 10.2 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed

7877 N Port Washington Rd, Glendale, WI 53217

Call (414) 352-4150 School facts Website Compare

Atonement Lutheran School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 381 students 15.8 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

4224 W Ruby Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53209

Call (414) 871-1224 School facts Website Compare

Hope Christian School: Fidelis

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades PreK-8 551 students 30.6 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed

4200 W Douglas Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53209

Call (414) 203-5270 School facts Website Compare

Clara Mohammed School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee) Grades K-12 73 students 14.6 students per teacher Islamic Co-ed

317 W Wright St., Milwaukee, WI 53212

Call (414) 263-6772 School facts Website Compare

Cross Trainers Academy

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-12 453 students 13.1 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed 13% to 4-year college

1530 W Center St., Milwaukee, WI 53206

Call (414) 935-0500 School facts Website Compare

St. Marcus Lutheran School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 956 students 18.4 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

2215 N Palmer St., Milwaukee, WI 53212

Call (414) 267-8381 School facts Compare

Blessed Savior Catholic School - East Campus

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 148 students 10.6 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

5140 N 55th St., Milwaukee, WI 53218

Call (414) 438-2745 School facts Website Compare

Academy of Excellence School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Racine, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 250 students 19.2 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed

4200 N 51st Blvd, Milwaukee, WI 53216

Call (414) 212-8023 School facts Compare

Tamarack Waldorf School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 191 students 11.7 students per teacher Nonsectarian Co-ed

Member of the Association of Waldorf Schools of North America

1150 E Brady St., Milwaukee, WI 53202

Call (414) 277-0009 School facts Website Compare

Yeshiva Elementary School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 189 students 9.2 students per teacher Jewish Co-ed

5115 W Keefe Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53216

Call (414) 871-9597 School facts Website Compare

On the state’s official list Other private schools

All 38 private elementary schools in Whitefish Bay or within 6 miles

School	Grades	Students	Per teacher	Affiliation	Miles
Holy Family Parish School ✓	PreK-8	141	10.1	Roman Catholic	<1
Bader Hillel Academy ✓	K-8	161	6	Jewish	1
Eastbrook Academy ✓	PreK-12	384	11.6	Christian (nondenominational)	2
St. Robert School ✓	PreK-8	261	11.2	Roman Catholic	2
Messmer Catholic Schools ✓	PreK-12	1,180	13.5	Roman Catholic	2
Divine Destiny School ✓	PreK-8	90	22.5	Christian (nondenominational)	2
Hope Christian School - Fortis ✓	PreK-8	319	21.3	Christian (nondenominational)	2
Garden Homes Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	238	21.6	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	2
Malaika Early Learning Center ✓	PreK-3	68	7.6	Nonsectarian	3
Believers in Christ Christian Academy ✓	PreK-12	145	11.5	Christian (nondenominational)	3
Siloah Lutheran School ✓	K-8	79	11.3	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	3
Carter's Christian Academy ✓	PreK-12	265	22.1	Christian (nondenominational)	3
St. Eugene School ✓	PreK-8	144	9.6	Roman Catholic	3
Hope Christian School-Semper ✓	PreK-8	497	24.9	Christian (nondenominational)	3
St. Johns Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	92	10.2	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	3
Atonement Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	381	15.8	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	3
Hope Christian School: Fidelis ✓	PreK-8	551	30.6	Christian (nondenominational)	3
Clara Mohammed School ✓	K-12	73	14.6	Islamic	3
Cross Trainers Academy ✓	PreK-12	453	13.1	Christian (nondenominational)	3
St. Marcus Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	956	18.4	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	4
Blessed Savior Catholic School - East Campus ✓	PreK-8	148	10.6	Roman Catholic	4
Academy of Excellence School ✓	PreK-8	250	19.2	Christian (nondenominational)	4
Tamarack Waldorf School ✓	PreK-8	191	11.7	Nonsectarian	4
Yeshiva Elementary School ✓	PreK-8	189	9.2	Jewish	4
Mt Lebanon Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	206	11.9	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	4
Mt Calvary Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	172	9.8	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	5
Mother of Good Counsel ✓	PreK-8	190	13.7	Roman Catholic	6
Early View Academy of Excellence ✓	PreK-12	254	14.1	Pentecostal	6
Pilgrim Lutheran School ✓	K-8	236	16.7	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	6
St. Sebastian School ✓	PreK-8	340	13.7	Roman Catholic	6
St. Coletta Day School of Milwaukee ✓	5-12	33	16.5	Roman Catholic	6
Mt Olive Christian Day School ✓	PreK-8	155	12	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	6
Messmer St. Rose Catholic School ✓	PreK-8	285	13.6	Roman Catholic	6
Northwest Lutheran School ✓	K-8	254	19.4	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	6
St. Monica School	PreK-8	333	10.7	Roman Catholic	<1
North Shore Montessori School	PreK-5	33	6.6	Nonsectarian	1
Milwaukee Jewish Day School	PreK-8	136	4.7	Jewish	1
St. Philips Lutheran School	PreK-8	81	14	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	3

Keep looking

What Wisconsin pays

Wisconsin Private School Choice Programs Scholarship

$11,305 a year for grades K to 8 and $13,799 for grades 9 to 12 in 2026-27 The Special Needs Scholarship is $16,477, a figure the state labels as estimated. Four year old kindergarten is paid at $6,783. The state notes that all 2026-27 amounts can still change by statute.

Figures read from each program’s official pages, October 2, 2026. Sources and how to apply

Get one email when applications open

Most programs open once a year, and several ran out of money or seats in 2026. Pick your state (you are looking at Whitefish Bay) and we will email you the day the next window opens, with the official link. That is the only email you get.

One email per application window. No calls, no sharing your details.