Private elementary schools in Whitefish Bay, WI
51 in Whitefish Bay or within 6 miles. 47 are on the state’s WI Choice list. Private schools that teach any grade from kindergarten through 5, going by each school’s grade span in the federal survey (or, for schools new since then, the state’s official list).
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-8141 students10.1 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades K-8161 students6 students per teacherJewishCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide)Grades PreK-12373 students11.6 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed100% to 4-year college
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-8226 students11.2 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-121,180 students13.5 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed65% to 4-year college
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-831 students
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-865 students22.5 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-8280 students21.3 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide)Grades PreK-8248 students21.6 students per teacherWisconsin Evangelical Lutheran SynodCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-680 students
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-384 students7.6 students per teacherNonsectarianCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-12139 students11.5 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed100% to 4-year college
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-8247 students
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-8126 students11.3 students per teacherWisconsin Evangelical Lutheran SynodCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-12259 students22.1 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed100% to 4-year college
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-8159 students9.6 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-8465 students24.9 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed
Right Step
3 mi✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades 5-1237 students
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide)Grades PreK-884 students10.2 students per teacherLutheran Church (Missouri Synod)Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-8307 students15.8 students per teacherWisconsin Evangelical Lutheran SynodCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-8555 students30.6 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee)Grades PreK-1249 students14.6 students per teacherIslamicCo-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-12477 students13.1 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed13% to 4-year college
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship)Grades PreK-8187 students
The other 27 private elementary schools, by name
- St. Marcus Lutheran School, Milwaukee
- Northwest Catholic School, Milwaukee
- Blessed Savior Catholic School - East Campus, Milwaukee
- Academy of Excellence School, Milwaukee
- Tamarack Waldorf School, Milwaukee
- Hope Christian School Prima, Milwaukee
- Yeshiva Elementary School, Milwaukee
- Mt Lebanon Lutheran School, Milwaukee
- Mt Calvary Lutheran School, Milwaukee
- Saint Catherine School, Milwaukee
- Jo's Learning Academy, Milwaukee
- King's Academy Christian School, Milwaukee
- Universal Scholars Academy, Milwaukee
- Mother of Good Counsel, Milwaukee
- Saint Peter Immanuel Lutheran School, Milwaukee
- Early View Academy of Excellence, Milwaukee
- Pilgrim Lutheran School, Wauwatosa
- St. Sebastian School, Milwaukee
- St. Coletta Day School of Milwaukee, Milwaukee
- Mt Olive Christian Day School, Milwaukee
- Saint Rose, Milwaukee
- Messmer St. Rose Catholic School, Milwaukee
- Northwest Lutheran School, Milwaukee
- St. Monica School, Whitefish Bay
- North Shore Montessori School, Glendale
- Milwaukee Jewish Day School, Milwaukee
- St. Philips Lutheran School, Milwaukee
Private elementary schools near Whitefish Bay by the numbers
- Where
- 2 in Whitefish Bay, 49 within 6 miles
- Students
- about 11,957 in all; the typical school has 188
- Smallest and largest
- Jo's Learning Academy, 27 students; Messmer Catholic Schools, 1,180 students
- Students per teacher
- 13.5 typical, 4.7 to 30.6 across 38 schools
- Association members
- 8, most often the National Catholic Educational Association
- To a 4-year college
- 100% of graduates at the typical high school (6 reporting)
- State program
- Scholarship, $11,305 a year for grades K to 8 and $13,799 for grades 9 to 12 in 2026-27
How WI Choice works
- Catholic10
- Christian, not Catholic21
- Jewish3
- Islamic1
- Nonsectarian3
- Not in federal survey13
- Under 506
- 50 to 14914
- 150 to 29921
- 300 to 5998
- 600 or more2
- Private elementary schools here92%
- All of Wisconsin60%
Lowest$4,800Middle$9,000Highest$14,750
Where these facts come from
- Grades, size, affiliation, co-ed, membership, college-going: NCES Private School Universe Survey 2023-24, downloaded September 20, 2026.
- 2025-26 enrollment, 43 schools: Wisconsin DPI, certified private school enrollment 2025-26, downloaded October 6, 2026.
- Program list: Wisconsin Private School Choice Programs schools, list dated October 14, 2026, checked November 9, 2026.
- Award and rules: Wisconsin Private School Choice Programs, official page, read October 2, 2026.
- Tuition for 11 schools: each school’s own website, last read October 6, 2026.
Keep looking
- All private schools near Whitefish Bay
- Christian schools in Whitefish Bay
- Catholic schools in Whitefish Bay
- Private high schools in Whitefish Bay
- Private middle schools in Whitefish Bay
- Private schools with kindergarten in Whitefish Bay
- Private schools with pre-K in Whitefish Bay
- Jewish schools in Whitefish Bay
- Lutheran schools in Whitefish Bay
- Montessori schools in Whitefish Bay
- All-girls schools in Whitefish Bay
- All-boys schools in Whitefish Bay
- Private elementary schools in Glendale (2 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Milwaukee (5 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Wauwatosa (8 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Mequon (9 mi)
- Private elementary schools in West Allis (10 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Brookfield (11 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Menomonee Falls (12 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Greenfield (12 mi)
- Private elementary schools across Wisconsin
Put the next WI Choice window in your calendar
Open now, until November 20, 2026 Wisconsin WI Choice: Milwaukee Parental Choice Program: application period.
Every program's dates in one calendar that updates when we confirm new dates: subscribe in Google Calendar · subscribe in Apple Calendar or Outlook · all deadlines
Free. Nothing to sign up for: the calendar file is made in your browser and nothing is sent to us. Dates can change, so confirm on the official site.