Private elementary schools in West Allis, WI (49)

On the official list

Affiliation, co-ed or single-sex, association membership and the share of graduates going on to a 4-year college come from the 2023-24 federal Private School Universe survey.

Living Hope Lutheran School

under 1 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 132 students 12 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

2217 S 99th St., West Allis, WI 53227

Call (414) 321-8780 School facts Website Compare

St. Pauls Lutheran School

under 1 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 124 students 10 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed

7821 W Lincoln Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53219

Call (414) 541-6251 School facts Website Compare

Grace Christian Academy

1 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades K-12 177 students 10.9 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed 0% to 4-year college

Member of the Association of Christian Schools International

8420 W Beloit Rd, West Allis, WI 53227

Call (414) 327-4200 School facts Website Compare

St. Matthias Parish School

1 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 173 students 13.5 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

9300 W Beloit Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53227

Call (414) 321-0894 School facts Website Compare

Mary Queen of Saints Catholic Academy-Greenfield

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades K-8 162 students 12.7 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

1227 S 116th St., West Allis, WI 53214

Call (414) 769-3300 School facts Website Compare

St. Vincent Pallotti School

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 173 students 14.5 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

201 N 76th St., Milwaukee, WI 53213

Call (414) 258-4165 School facts Website Compare

St. Gregory the Great School

2 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 181 students 17.4 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

3132 S 63rd St., Milwaukee, WI 53219

Call (414) 321-1350 School facts Website Compare

St. John the Evangelist School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 147 students 13.9 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

8500 W Coldspring Rd, Greenfield, WI 53228

Call (414) 321-8540 School facts Compare

St. Johns Lutheran School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 304 students 15.7 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

4001 S 68th St., Milwaukee, WI 53220

Call (414) 541-5881 School facts Website Compare

St. John's Evangelical Lutheran School

3 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 166 students 15.1 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

1278 Dewey Ave, Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Call (414) 258-4214 School facts Website Compare

St. Jacobi Evangelical Lutheran School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 191 students 18.5 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

8605 W Forest Home Ave, Greenfield, WI 53228

Call (414) 425-2040 School facts Website Compare

Heritage Christian Schools

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-12 610 students 11.9 students per teacher Christian (nondenominational) Co-ed 77% to 4-year college

Member of the Association of Christian Schools International

3500 S Glen Park Rd, New Berlin, WI 53151

Call (262) 432-0333 School facts Website Compare

Nativity Jesuit Academy

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 232 students 13.6 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

1515 S 29th St., Milwaukee, WI 53215

Call (414) 618-4005 School facts Website Compare

Mt Olive Christian Day School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) Grades PreK-8 155 students 12 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed

5301 W Washington Blvd, Milwaukee, WI 53208

Call (414) 774-2200 School facts Website Compare

St. Sebastian School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 340 students 13.7 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

1747 N 54th St., Milwaukee, WI 53208

Call (414) 453-5830 School facts Website Compare

St. Coletta Day School of Milwaukee

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship) Grades 5-12 33 students 16.5 students per teacher Roman Catholic Special education Co-ed

1740 N 55th St., Milwaukee, WI 53208

Call (414) 453-1850 School facts Website Compare

St. Mary Parish School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 307 students 11.8 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

9553 W Edgerton Ave, Hales Corners, WI 53130

Call (414) 425-3100 School facts Website Compare

Christ King School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 226 students 9.7 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

2646 N Swan Blvd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226

Call (414) 258-4160 School facts Website Compare

Notre Dame School of Milwaukee

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-4 307 students 16.2 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

1425 S 26th St., Milwaukee, WI 53204

Call (414) 316-3291 School facts Website Compare

Messmer St. Rose Catholic School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 285 students 13.6 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

514 N 31st St., Milwaukee, WI 53208

Call (414) 264-5440 School facts Compare

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades 3-12 100 students 8.4 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Special education Co-ed 0% to 4-year college

5425 S 111th St., Hales Corners, WI 53130

Call (414) 461-8500 School facts Website Compare

Christ-St. Peter Lutheran School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 236 students 13.9 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed

2229 W Greenfield Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53204

Call (414) 383-2055 School facts Website Compare

Pilgrim Lutheran School

4 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades K-8 236 students 16.7 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed

6717 W Center St., Wauwatosa, WI 53210

Call (414) 354-6601 School facts Website Compare

St. Adalbert Elementary School

5 mi

✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades K-8 385 students 16.7 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed

Member of the National Catholic Educational Association

1913 W Becher St., Milwaukee, WI 53215

Call (414) 645-5450 School facts Website Compare

On the state’s official list Other private schools

All 49 private elementary schools in West Allis or within 6 miles

School	Grades	Students	Per teacher	Affiliation	Miles
Living Hope Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	132	12	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	<1
St. Pauls Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	124	10	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	<1
Grace Christian Academy ✓	K-12	177	10.9	Christian (nondenominational)	1
St. Matthias Parish School ✓	PreK-8	173	13.5	Roman Catholic	1
Mary Queen of Saints Catholic Academy-Greenfield ✓	K-8	162	12.7	Roman Catholic	2
St. Vincent Pallotti School ✓	PreK-8	173	14.5	Roman Catholic	2
St. Gregory the Great School ✓	PreK-8	181	17.4	Roman Catholic	2
St. John the Evangelist School ✓	PreK-8	147	13.9	Roman Catholic	3
St. Johns Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	304	15.7	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	3
St. John's Evangelical Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	166	15.1	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	3
St. Jacobi Evangelical Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	191	18.5	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	4
Heritage Christian Schools ✓	PreK-12	610	11.9	Christian (nondenominational)	4
Nativity Jesuit Academy ✓	PreK-8	232	13.6	Roman Catholic	4
Mt Olive Christian Day School ✓	PreK-8	155	12	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	4
St. Sebastian School ✓	PreK-8	340	13.7	Roman Catholic	4
St. Coletta Day School of Milwaukee ✓	5-12	33	16.5	Roman Catholic	4
St. Mary Parish School ✓	PreK-8	307	11.8	Roman Catholic	4
Christ King School ✓	PreK-8	226	9.7	Roman Catholic	4
Notre Dame School of Milwaukee ✓	PreK-4	307	16.2	Roman Catholic	4
Messmer St. Rose Catholic School ✓	PreK-8	285	13.6	Roman Catholic	4
Journeys Lutheran School ✓	3-12	100	8.4	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	4
Christ-St. Peter Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	236	13.9	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	4
Pilgrim Lutheran School ✓	K-8	236	16.7	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	4
St. Adalbert Elementary School ✓	K-8	385	16.7	Roman Catholic	5
Mother of Good Counsel ✓	PreK-8	190	13.7	Roman Catholic	5
St. Joseph Academy ✓	PreK-8	389	15	Roman Catholic	5
Star of Bethlehem Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	220	23.4	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	5
St. Alphonsus School ✓	PreK-8	120	9.2	Roman Catholic	5
Mt Calvary Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	172	9.8	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	5
Hales Corners Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	476	15.1	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	5
St. Anthony School ✓	PreK-12	1,436	17.2	Roman Catholic	5
St. Josaphat Parish School ✓	PreK-8	198	16.5	Roman Catholic	5
St. Margaret Mary ✓	K-8	139	10.7	Roman Catholic	6
St. Augustine Preparatory Academy ✓	PreK-12	1,759	14.5	Christian (nondenominational)	6
Yeshiva Elementary School ✓	PreK-8	189	9.2	Jewish	6
Shining Star Christian Schools ✓	PreK-9	777	26.5	Christian (nondenominational)	6
Northwest Lutheran School ✓	K-8	254	19.4	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	6
Milwaukee Montessori School	PreK-8	206	6	Nonsectarian	2
St. Jude the Apostle School	PreK-8	351	12.5	Roman Catholic	2
St. Sava Orthodox School	PreK-8	69	8.1	Other religious	3
Notre Dame School of Milwaukee	PreK-8	618	15.5	Roman Catholic	3
Children's Workshop	K	2	not reported	Nonsectarian	3
St. Mary Visitation School	PreK-8	290	13.7	Roman Catholic	4
Our Redeemer Lutheran School	PreK-8	83	5.7	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	4
Doxa Christian Academy	K-6	27	8.2	Christian (nondenominational)	4
Messiah Lutheran School	PreK-7	19	5.6	Lutheran	4
St. Martini Lutheran Grade School	K-8	158	13.3	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	5
St. John Paul II Catholic School	PreK-8	170	17	Roman Catholic	5
Brookfield Christian School	PreK-8	266	12.7	Calvinist	6

Keep looking

What Wisconsin pays

Wisconsin Private School Choice Programs Scholarship

$11,305 a year for grades K to 8 and $13,799 for grades 9 to 12 in 2026-27 The Special Needs Scholarship is $16,477, a figure the state labels as estimated. Four year old kindergarten is paid at $6,783. The state notes that all 2026-27 amounts can still change by statute.

Figures read from each program’s official pages, October 2, 2026. Sources and how to apply

Get one email when applications open

Most programs open once a year, and several ran out of money or seats in 2026. Pick your state (you are looking at West Allis) and we will email you the day the next window opens, with the official link. That is the only email you get.

One email per application window. No calls, no sharing your details.