Star of Bethlehem Lutheran School, New Berlin, WI

Star of Bethlehem Lutheran School is a Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod private school in New Berlin, WI teaching grades PreK-8. It reported 220 students and about 23.4 students for every teacher in the 2023-24 federal survey. It is on Wisconsin’s official WI Choice list.

Can you use WI Choice here?

✓ On the official Wisconsin Private School Choice (Milwaukee, Statewide) list Confirmed open

The state’s own list includes this school. We last read that list on 2026-08-04. See the official source. Lists change, so confirm with the school before you enroll.

Call (262) 786-2901 Visit website Directions Add to compare

School facts

Grades: PreK-8
Students: 220
Teachers: 10
Students per teacher: 23.4
Student body: Coeducational
Program: Regular
Affiliation: Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod
Setting: Suburb

These are the numbers the school gave the U.S. Department of Education for the 2023-24 school year, published in July 2026. Enrollment and staffing move every year, so ask the school for today’s figures. Where this comes from. Something wrong? Tell us and we will fix it.

What Wisconsin pays, and what that leaves you

WI

Wisconsin Private School Choice Programs Scholarship

$11,305 a year for grades K to 8 and $13,799 for grades 9 to 12 in 2026-27 The Special Needs Scholarship is $16,477, a figure the state labels as estimated. Four year old kindergarten is paid at $6,783. The state notes that all 2026-27 amounts can still change by statute.

Figures read from each program’s official pages, 2026-09-21. Sources and how to apply

What would you pay at Star of Bethlehem Lutheran School?

Yearly tuition the school quoted Fees, books, uniforms WI Choice award Children

WI Choice pays between $11,305 and $13,799 depending on your household. We start with the lower figure. Change it if you know yours. An award can never be more than the school actually charges. This is arithmetic, not a quote.

Other private schools nearby

School	Grades	Students	Per teacher	Affiliation	Miles
Heritage Christian Schools ✓	PreK-12	610	11.9	Christian (nondenominational)	1
Doxa Christian Academy	K-6	27	8.2	Christian (nondenominational)	2
Messiah Lutheran School	PreK-7	19	5.6	Lutheran	3
Hales Corners Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	476	15.1	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	4
St. Pauls Lutheran School ✓	PreK-8	243	21.3	Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod	4
Journeys Lutheran School ✓	3-12	100	8.4	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)	4
Mary Queen of Saints Catholic Academy-Greenfield ✓	K-8	162	12.7	Roman Catholic	4
Trinity Lutheran Classical High School ✓					5

On the state’s official list Other private schools

Keep looking

Do you run this school?

Fix anything that is off, and add what families ask us for most: tuition, open seats by grade, and photos. It is free.

Update this listing

Get one email when applications open

Most programs open once a year, and several ran out of money or seats in 2026. Pick your state and we will email you the day the next window opens, with the official link. That is the only email you get.

One email per application window. No calls, no sharing your details.