ChoiceFunded What your state pays

Private schools in Fishers, IN

57 schools within 12 miles. 29 of them are on the state’s Choice Scholarship list. Choice Scholarship pays about $6,000 to $8,300, set by your home school district.

Schools near Fishers

Schools on the official Choice Scholarship list are first, then it goes by distance. No school pays to appear here or to move up.

On the state’s official list Other private schools

All 57 schools within 12 miles

School Grades Students Per teacher Affiliation Miles
Fishers Christian Academy ✓ PreK-12 134 10.3 Baptist <1
Mission Christian Academy ✓ <1
Eman Schools ✓ PreK-12 373 8.2 Islamic 2
Premier Soccer Academy ✓ 3
St. Simon the Apostle School ✓ PreK-8 592 13.6 Roman Catholic 5
Holy Cross Lutheran School ✓ PreK-8 391 195.5 Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) 5
Horizon Christian School ✓ K-12 343 10.4 Christian (nondenominational) 5
Guerin Catholic High School ✓ 6
Legacy Christian School ✓ PreK-12 245 13.6 Christian (nondenominational) 6
Carmel Latin School (West Campus) ✓ 6
The Performing Arts Conservatory ✓ 6
Heritage Christian School ✓ PreK-12 1,476 11.6 Christian (nondenominational) 7
Our Lady of Grace School ✓ K-8 380 17.3 Roman Catholic 7
Future Edge Academy ✓ 7
Northpoint Christian Academy ✓ 7
Inspire Academy ✓ 8
Cornerstone Baptist Academy ✓ PreK-12 79 6.6 Baptist 8
Colonial Christian School ✓ PreK-12 245 13.6 Baptist 8
Our Lady of Mount Carmel ✓ K-8 654 12 Roman Catholic 8
Union Bible Academy ✓ K 70 9.5 Christian (nondenominational) 8
Saint Pius X School ✓ 9
Tp Schools ✓ PreK-8 254 18.1 Pentecostal 9
Cathedral High School ✓ PreK-12 1,171 12.6 Roman Catholic 9
Saint Lawrence School ✓ 9
Indianapolis Junior Academy ✓ 1-8 53 12.9 Seventh-Day Adventist 9
Bishop Chatard High School ✓ 10
Immaculate Heart of Mary Catholic School ✓ K-8 410 18.3 Roman Catholic 11
University High School of Indiana ✓ 9-12 358 10.4 Nonsectarian 11
Hasten Hebrew Academy of Indianapolis ✓ PreK-8 66 3.2 Jewish 12
Noah's Ark Preschool & Kindergarten PreK-K 13 6.5 Evangelical Lutheran Church in America <1
Community Montessori School PreK-6 24 8 Nonsectarian 2
St. Louis de Montfort Catholic School PreK-8 492 16.8 Roman Catholic 2
Primrose School of Noblesville PreK-K 12 12 Nonsectarian 3
Primrose School at Gray Eagle PreK-K 30 11.5 Nonsectarian 4
Fall Creek Montessori Academy PreK-K 5 1 Nonsectarian 4
Worthmore Academy Ungraded 45 5 Nonsectarian 5
St. Theodore Guerin High School 9-12 800 13.5 Roman Catholic 5
Primrose School at Bridgewater PreK-K 22 7.3 Nonsectarian 5
St. Elizabeth Seton Preschool and Kindergarten PreK-K 14 14 Roman Catholic 6
Highlands Latin School PreK-12 176 8 Christian (nondenominational) 6
Midwest Academy 9-12 111 9.2 Nonsectarian 8
Fortune Academy 2-12 94 3.8 Nonsectarian 8
Coram Deo Academy PreK-10 225 12.6 Other religious 8
Peter Rabbit Nursery School PreK-K 18 9 Nonsectarian 8
Montessori School of Westfield PreK-8 103 6.9 Nonsectarian 8
St. Lawrence Catholic School PreK-8 196 11.5 Roman Catholic 9
St. Matthew Catholic School PreK-8 320 12.2 Roman Catholic 10
Park Tudor School PreK-12 956 10.1 Nonsectarian 10
St. Maria Goretti School PreK-8 417 17.8 Roman Catholic 10
St. Luke Catholic School K 57 1.2 Roman Catholic 10
A Children's Habitat Montessori School PreK-5 42 5.7 Nonsectarian 11
Primrose School at West Clay PreK-K 30 15 Nonsectarian 11
International Montessori School PreK-3 27 6.8 Nonsectarian 11
Northside Montessori PreK-6 22 4 Nonsectarian 11
Indiana Montessori Academy PreK-K 31 10.3 Nonsectarian 12
The Orchard School PreK-8 444 4.5 Nonsectarian 12
Cicero Sda Elementary 1-8 21 10.5 Seventh-Day Adventist 12

What Indiana pays, and what that leaves you

IN
Indiana Choice Scholarship Scholarship
About $6,000 to $8,300, set by your home school district These are the state’s 2026-27 estimates. The award is the lesser of that figure or the school’s tuition and fees.

Figures read from each program’s official pages, 2026-09-20. Sources and how to apply

What would you pay?

Choice Scholarship pays between $6,033 and $8,329 depending on your household. We start with the lower figure. Change it if you know yours. An award can never be more than the school actually charges. This is arithmetic, not a quote.

Keep looking

Get one email when applications open

Most programs open once a year, and several ran out of money or seats in 2026. Pick your state (you are looking at Fishers) and we will email you the day the next window opens, with the official link. That is the only email you get.

One email per application window. No calls, no sharing your details.

Questions parents ask

How many private schools are there near Fishers?

We count 57 within 12 miles of downtown Fishers. Together they enrolled about 12,041 students in the last federal survey (2023-24). The largest is Heritage Christian School with 1,476 students.

Which Fishers private schools take Choice Scholarship?

29 of the 57 schools on this page are on the state’s official Choice Scholarship list. They are marked with a green check and listed first. Schools marked here appear on the 2026-27 participating schools sheet published by the Indiana Department of Education.

Will Choice Scholarship cover the whole tuition bill?

Sometimes, but do not count on it. Choice Scholarship pays about $6,000 to $8,300, set by your home school district, and schools set their own prices. Ask each school for tuition plus fees, then use the calculator on this page to see what is left for you to pay.

See schools What you pay