St. Johns Lutheran School
under 1 mi ✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide, Special Needs Scholarship) Grades PreK-8 145 students 12.7 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed
Private elementary schools in Mayville, WI
9 in Mayville or within 12 miles. 7 are on the state’s WI Choice list. Private schools that teach any grade from kindergarten through 5, going by the grade span each school gave the federal survey.
Affiliation, co-ed or single-sex, association membership and the share of graduates going on to a 4-year college come from the 2023-24 federal Private School Universe survey.
St. Mary Catholic School
under 1 mi ✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide) Grades PreK-3 31 students 5.3 students per teacher Roman Catholic Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide) Grades PreK-7 11 students 6.9 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide) Grades PreK-7 47 students 9.4 students per teacher Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod) Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide) Grades PreK-8 60 students 10.3 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed
✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide) Grades PreK-8 58 students 7.6 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed
Bethany Lutheran School
11 mi ✓ Wisconsin Private School Choice (Statewide) Grades PreK-8 40 students 11.4 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed
Grades PreK-12 39 students 4.5 students per teacher Pentecostal Co-ed 0% to 4-year college
Grades PreK-8 36 students 7.8 students per teacher Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod Co-ed
On the state’s official list Other private schools
Keep looking
- All private schools near Mayville
- Christian schools in Mayville
- Lutheran schools in Mayville
- Private elementary schools in Beaver Dam (14 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Campbellsport (15 mi)
- Private elementary schools in West Bend (19 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Fond Du Lac (20 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Jackson (23 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Watertown (23 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Hubertus (24 mi)
- Private elementary schools in Columbus (27 mi)
- Private elementary schools across Wisconsin
What Wisconsin pays
Wisconsin Private School Choice Programs Scholarship
$11,305 a year for grades K to 8 and $13,799 for grades 9 to 12 in 2026-27 The Special Needs Scholarship is $16,477, a figure the state labels as estimated. Four year old kindergarten is paid at $6,783. The state notes that all 2026-27 amounts can still change by statute.
Figures read from each program’s official pages, October 2, 2026. Sources and how to apply
Get one email when applications open
Most programs open once a year, and several ran out of money or seats in 2026. Pick your state (you are looking at Mayville) and we will email you the day the next window opens, with the official link. That is the only email you get.
One email per application window. No calls, no sharing your details.