ChoiceFunded Search

Private schools in Erie County, NY

51 schools across Alden, Amherst, Bowmansville, Buffalo and other towns. About 9,533 students in all (2023-24).

More filters
SchoolCityGradesStudentsPer teacherAffiliation
St. John the Baptist SchoolAldenPreK-81026.6Roman Catholic
Autism ServicesAmherstUngraded966Nonsectarian
CHC Learning CenterAmherstPreK415.9Nonsectarian
Christ the King Elementary SchoolAmherstPreK-81178.5Roman Catholic
Jewish Heritage Day School/Ohr TemimimAmherstPreK-11665.3Jewish
St. Benedict SchoolAmherstPreK-832512.8Roman Catholic
Chesterton Academy of BuffaloBowmansville9-12294.1Roman Catholic
Bishop Timon-St. Jude High SchoolBuffalo9-1227911Roman Catholic, all-boys
Buffalo SeminaryBuffalo9-121496.4Nonsectarian, all-girls
Catholic Academy West BuffaloBuffaloPreK-817010.6Roman Catholic
Darul Uloom Al MadaniaBuffaloPreK-1127710.7Islamic
Mount Mercy AcademyBuffalo9-121808.4Roman Catholic, all-girls
Mount St. Mary AcademyBuffalo9-122168.2Roman Catholic, all-girls
Nichols SchoolBuffalo5-125828Nonsectarian
Notre Dame AcademyBuffaloPreK-837614.2Roman Catholic
Saints Tabernacle School of ExcellenceBuffalo2-11164Church of God in Christ
St. Josephs Collegiate InstituteBuffalo9-1264713.8Roman Catholic, all-boys
St. Mark SchoolBuffaloPreK-836211.3Roman Catholic
Stanley G Falk SchoolBuffaloK-125545.1Nonsectarian
Aspire of Wny/Ctr for LearningCheektowagaPreK1317.7Nonsectarian
Stanley G. Falk SchoolCheektowaga7-121365Nonsectarian
The Arc Erie County New YorkCheektowagaUngraded1476.1Nonsectarian
Beyond Learning CenterDepewPreK2025.5Nonsectarian
Our Lady of the Blessed Sacrament SchoolDepewPreK-2285.3Roman Catholic
St. Marys SchoolEast AmherstPreK-81638.6Roman Catholic
Immaculate Conception SchoolEast AuroraK-816411.6Roman Catholic
St. Stephen SchoolGrand IslandK-81337.8Roman Catholic
Ss Peter & Paul Elementary SchoolHamburgPreK-81388.2Roman Catholic
St. Francis High SchoolHamburg9-1241614.6Roman Catholic, all-boys
BakerLackawannaK-121397Nonsectarian
Baker Hall SchoolLackawannaPreK-121935.2Nonsectarian
Our Lady of Victory SchoolLackawannaPreK-81007.2Roman Catholic
Southtowns Catholic SchoolLake ViewPreK-81198.2Roman Catholic
Buffalo Suburban Christian AcademyLancasterK-8178.5Seventh-Day Adventist
St. Marys Elementary SchoolLancasterPreK-82069.8Roman Catholic
St. Marys High SchoolLancaster9-1240613.1Roman Catholic
Nativity of Our Lord SchoolOrchard ParkPreK-817011.4Roman Catholic
St. John Vianney SchoolOrchard ParkPreK-81086.4Roman Catholic
The Park School of BuffaloSnyderPreK-122365.1Nonsectarian
Cardinal O'Hara High SchoolTonawanda9-121818.6Roman Catholic
New Life Christian SchoolTonawandaK-12289.3Christian (nondenominational)
St. Christopher Elementary SchoolTonawandaPreK-82239.9Roman Catholic
Aurora Waldorf SchoolWest FallsPreK-81049.2Nonsectarian
Center Road Christian AcademyWest SenecaK-1063Christian (nondenominational)
Queen of Heaven SchoolWest SenecaPreK-831011.2Roman Catholic
Trinity Lutheran SchoolWest SenecaPreK-8779.1Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)
West Seneca Christian SchoolWest SenecaPreK-121086.9Baptist
Christian Central AcademyWilliamsvillePreK-122207.7Christian (nondenominational)
Gateway-Longview Lynde SchoolWilliamsvilleK-121233.8Nonsectarian
Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary SchoolWilliamsvillePreK-815210.5Roman Catholic
St. Peter and Paul SchoolWilliamsvillePreK-8653.8Roman Catholic

Erie County private schools at a glance

Towns
19; the most in Buffalo (12), Amherst (5) and West Seneca (4)
Among New York counties
7th most private schools of 60; 4% of the state’s 1,152
Typical school
152 students (47 reporting)
Smallest and largest
Saints Tabernacle School of Excellence, 16 students; St. Josephs Collegiate Institute, 647 students
Students per teacher
8.2 typical, 3 to 14.6 across 51 schools
Programs
10 special education
Co-ed or single-sex
3 all-girls and 3 all-boys; the rest co-ed
Association members
22, most often the National Catholic Educational Association
To a 4-year college
85% of graduates at the typical high school (19 reporting)
State program
No state program pays private school tuition
What is available
Public charter schools
21 in the county, tuition-free and not counted here
Charter schools in New York

Where these facts come from

New York has no state program today

New York has no program that pays private school tuition today. It could still start one, or opt in to the federal scholarship tax credit that starts in 2027.

How the federal credit works · Every state's application dates

Find a school What your state pays