Private high schools in Amherst, NY
14 in Amherst or within 6 miles. Private schools that teach grade 9 or above, going by each school’s grade span in the federal survey (or, for schools new since then, the state’s official list).
Grades PreK-12236 students5.1 students per teacherNonsectarianAlternativeCo-ed70% to 4-year college
Grades 9-12647 students13.8 students per teacherRoman CatholicAll-boys96% to 4-year college
Nichols School
3 miGrades 5-12582 students8 students per teacherNonsectarianCo-ed87% to 4-year college
Grades PreK-12220 students7.7 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed91% to 4-year college
Grades PreK-1166 students5.3 students per teacherJewishCo-ed
Grades 9-12181 students8.6 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed89% to 4-year college
Grades 9-12216 students8.2 students per teacherRoman CatholicAll-girls91% to 4-year college
Grades K-1228 students9.3 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed67% to 4-year college
Grades 2-1116 students4 students per teacherChurch of God in ChristCo-ed
Grades K-12123 students3.8 students per teacherNonsectarianSpecial educationCo-ed0% to 4-year college
Buffalo Seminary
5 miGrades 9-12149 students6.4 students per teacherNonsectarianAll-girls95% to 4-year college
Grades PreK-11277 students10.7 students per teacherIslamicSpecial program emphasisCo-ed
Grades K-12554 students5.1 students per teacherNonsectarianSpecial educationCo-ed25% to 4-year college
Grades 7-12136 students5 students per teacherNonsectarianSpecial educationCo-ed0% to 4-year college
Private high schools near Amherst by the numbers
- Where
- 1 in Amherst, 13 within 6 miles
- Students
- about 3,431 in all; the typical school has 216
- Smallest and largest
- Saints Tabernacle School of Excellence, 16 students; St. Josephs Collegiate Institute, 647 students
- Students per teacher
- 7.7 typical, 3.8 to 13.8 across 14 schools
- Co-ed or single-sex
- 2 all-girls and 1 all-boys; the rest co-ed
- Association members
- 3, most often the National Catholic Educational Association
- To a 4-year college
- 87% of graduates at the typical high school (11 reporting)
- Verified tuition
- St. Josephs Collegiate Institute $17,785; Nichols School $30,175
- State program
- No state program pays private school tuition
What is available
- Catholic3
- Christian, not Catholic3
- Jewish1
- Islamic1
- Nonsectarian6
- Under 502
- 50 to 1494
- 150 to 2995
- 300 to 5992
- 600 or more1
Where these facts come from
- Grades, size, affiliation, co-ed, membership, college-going: NCES Private School Universe Survey 2023-24, downloaded September 20, 2026.
- State aid for private school: official state source, read October 20, 2026.
- Tuition for 2 schools: each school’s own website, last read October 5, 2026.
Keep looking
- All private schools near Amherst
- Christian schools in Amherst
- Catholic schools in Amherst
- Special education schools in Amherst
- Private elementary schools in Amherst
- Private middle schools in Amherst
- Private schools with kindergarten in Amherst
- Private schools with pre-K in Amherst
- All-girls schools in Amherst
- Private high schools in Williamsville (3 mi)
- Private high schools in Cheektowaga (5 mi)
- Private high schools in Tonawanda (5 mi)
- Private high schools in Buffalo (6 mi)
- Private high schools in Lancaster (8 mi)
- Private high schools in West Seneca (9 mi)
- Private high schools in Lackawanna (10 mi)
- Private high schools in Rochester (62 mi)
- Private high schools across New York
New York has no state program today
New York has no program that pays private school tuition today. It could still start one, or opt in to the federal scholarship tax credit that starts in 2027.
How the federal credit works · Every state's application dates