Private high schools in New Haven, IN
11 in New Haven or within 12 miles. 7 are on the state’s Choice Scholarship list. Private schools that teach grade 9 or above, going by each school’s grade span in the federal survey (or, for schools new since then, the state’s official list).
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades PreK-121,145 students19.1 students per teacherChristian (nondenominational)Co-ed84% to 4-year college
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades 3-1244 students8.8 students per teacherChurch of ChristAlternativeCo-ed
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades 9-12624 students12.5 students per teacherLutheran Church (Missouri Synod)Co-ed93% to 4-year college
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades 1-1118 students2.5 students per teacherIslamicCo-ed
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades 9-12532 students13 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed40% to 4-year college
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades PreK-11444 students9.8 students per teacherIslamicCo-ed
✓ Indiana Choice ScholarshipGrades 9-12917 students16.4 students per teacherRoman CatholicCo-ed76% to 4-year college
Grades 1-1045 students8.5 students per teacherLutheran Church (Missouri Synod)Special program emphasisCo-ed
Grades 1-1113 students5.7 students per teacherMennoniteCo-ed
Grades PreK-12100 students7.9 students per teacherChurch of ChristCo-ed40% to 4-year college
Gateway Woods School
11 miGrades 9-12Under 10 K-12 studentsOther religiousAlternativeCo-ed0% to 4-year college
Private high schools near New Haven by the numbers
- Where
- 0 in New Haven, 11 within 12 miles
- Students
- about 3,889 in all; the typical school has 444
- Smallest and largest
- Cuba Mennonite School, 13 students; Blackhawk Christian School, 1,145 students
- Students per teacher
- 9.8 typical, 2.5 to 19.1 across 10 schools
- Co-ed or single-sex
- all co-ed
- Association members
- 4, most often the Association of Christian Schools International
- To a 4-year college
- 76% of graduates at the typical high school (6 reporting)
- Verified tuition
- Concordia Lutheran High School $11,770; Bishop Luers High School $11,965; Bishop Dwenger High School $12,478
- State program
- Scholarship, about $6,000 to $8,300, set by your home school district
How Choice Scholarship works
- Catholic2
- Christian, not Catholic6
- Islamic2
- Other faiths1
- Under 504
- 50 to 1491
- 150 to 2990
- 300 to 5992
- 600 or more3
- Private high schools here64%
- All of Indiana66%
Where these facts come from
- Grades, size, affiliation, co-ed, membership, college-going: NCES Private School Universe Survey 2023-24, downloaded September 20, 2026.
- Program list: Indiana Choice Scholarship schools, list read November 15, 2026.
- Award and rules: Indiana Choice Scholarship, official page, read October 1, 2026.
- Tuition for 3 schools: each school’s own website, last read October 5, 2026.
Keep looking
- All private schools near New Haven
- Christian schools in New Haven
- Catholic schools in New Haven
- Private elementary schools in New Haven
- Private middle schools in New Haven
- Private schools with kindergarten in New Haven
- Private schools with pre-K in New Haven
- Lutheran schools in New Haven
- Private high schools in Fort Wayne (7 mi)
- Private high schools in Grabill (10 mi)
- Private high schools in Marion (49 mi)
- Private high schools in Goshen (55 mi)
- Private high schools in Middlebury (55 mi)
- Private high schools in Nappanee (57 mi)
- Private high schools in Bremen (65 mi)
- Private high schools in Elkhart (65 mi)
- Private high schools across Indiana
Put the next Choice Scholarship window in your calendar
Open now, until January 15, 2027 Indiana Choice Scholarship: Half-year application period (spring semester); the school files for you.
Every program's dates in one calendar that updates when we confirm new dates: subscribe in Google Calendar · subscribe in Apple Calendar or Outlook · all deadlines
Free. Nothing to sign up for: the calendar file is made in your browser and nothing is sent to us. Dates can change, so confirm on the official site.