34 Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN

More filters

On the official list

School	City	Grades	Students	Per teacher	Affiliation
Crossing National ✓	Elkhart	9-12	630	12.2	Christian (nondenominational)
Elkhart Christian Academy ✓	Elkhart	On the state list; not in the federal survey
Genai Excellence Academy ✓	Elkhart	PreK-4	14	2.3	Christian (nondenominational)
St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic School ✓	Elkhart	K-8	250	10.4	Roman Catholic
St. Vincent de Paul Elementary School ✓	Elkhart	PreK-8	177	13.6	Roman Catholic
The Early Learning Center at Hubbard Hill ✓	Elkhart	On the state list; not in the federal survey
Trinity Lutheran School ✓	Elkhart	PreK-8	279	13.1	Lutheran Church (Missouri Synod)
Bethany Christian Schools ✓	Goshen	1-12	316	12.4	Mennonite
Clinton Christian School ✓	Goshen	K-12	230	12.4	Christian (nondenominational)
St. John the Evangelist Catholic School ✓	Goshen	PreK-6	124	11.7	Roman Catholic
Cornerstone Christian Montessori School	Elkhart	PreK-6	32	6.4	Nonsectarian
Montessori School of Elkhart	Elkhart	PreK-K	10	10	Nonsectarian
Northern Maple Christian School	Elkhart	2-7	11	3.2	Mennonite
Bashor Alternative School	Goshen	K-12	72	6	Methodist
Clinton Center Amish	Goshen	1-8	39	9.8	Amish
Forest Grove School	Goshen	1-8	46	15.3	Amish
Hillside Amish School	Goshen	1-8	36	12	Amish
Hillside Mennonite W	Goshen	1-8	38	19	Mennonite
Peaceful Woods	Goshen	1-8	36	18	Amish
Powerline School	Goshen	1-8	39	13	Amish
Timber View School	Goshen	1-8	27	9	Amish
Woodlawn Christian School	Goshen	1-11	76	10	Mennonite
Birdsong Echos	Middlebury	1-7	25	12.5	Amish
Country Lane School	Middlebury	1-8	28	14	Amish
Eight Square Amish School	Middlebury	1-8	29	14.5	Amish
Pumpkinvine School	Middlebury	1-8	33	11	Amish
Country Echos	Nappanee	1-8	31	10.3	Amish
East Locke School	Nappanee	1-8	24	12	Amish
Meadow Valley School	Nappanee	1-8	24	12	Mennonite
Pine View	Nappanee	1-8	38	19	Amish
United Christian School	Nappanee	K-12	99	13.9	Mennonite
Weldy Amish School	Nappanee	1-8	37	12.3	Amish
Old Order Mennonite Garden Spot	Wakarusa	1-8	38	19	Mennonite
Wabash School	Wakarusa	1-8	31	15.5	Mennonite

Elkhart County private schools at a glance

Towns: 5; the most in Goshen (12), Elkhart (10) and Nappanee (6)
Among Indiana counties: 5th most private schools of 71; 5% of the state’s 642
Typical school: 38 students (31 reporting)
Smallest and largest: Northern Maple Christian School, 11 students; Crossing National, 630 students
Students per teacher: 12.3 typical, 2.3 to 19 across 32 schools
Programs: 2 Montessori
Association members: 5, most often the National Catholic Educational Association
To a 4-year college: 5% of graduates at the typical high school (5 reporting)
Verified tuition: Trinity Lutheran School $7,700
State program: Scholarship, about $6,000 to $8,300, set by your home school district
How Choice Scholarship works
Public charter schools: 2 in the county, tuition-free and not counted here
Charter schools in Indiana

Affiliation, 34 schools

Catholic3
Christian, not Catholic27
Nonsectarian2
Not in federal survey2

Grade levels (overlapping), 34 schools

Pre-K (and up)6
Elementary (K to 5)31
Middle (6 to 8)29
High school (9 to 12)6
K to 12, one school3

School size, 31 reporting

Under 5021
50 to 1494
150 to 2994
300 to 5991
600 or more1

On the Choice Scholarship list: 10 of 34

Elkhart County29%
All of Indiana66%

Where these facts come from

Grades, size, affiliation, co-ed, membership, college-going: NCES Private School Universe Survey 2023-24, downloaded September 20, 2026.
Program list: Indiana Choice Scholarship schools, list read October 26, 2026, checked October 28, 2026.
Award and rules: Indiana Choice Scholarship, official page, read October 1, 2026.
Tuition for 1 school: each school’s own website, last read October 1, 2026.
Public charter schools: NCES Common Core of Data, public school directory 2025-26 (preliminary), loaded October 8, 2026.

Cities in and around Elkhart County

Neighboring counties

Put the next Choice Scholarship window in your calendar

Open now, until January 15, 2027 Indiana Choice Scholarship: Half-year application period (spring semester); the school files for you.

Add to Google Calendar Official source

Every program's dates in one calendar that updates when we confirm new dates: subscribe in Google Calendar · subscribe in Apple Calendar or Outlook · all deadlines

Free. Nothing to sign up for: the calendar file is made in your browser and nothing is sent to us. Dates can change, so confirm on the official site.